The Amateur Eye – World Chess Championship – GAME 5

I am glad that I do not play at this super chess level. Examining this Giuoco Piano opening starts out as a mild mannered positional struggle with the ancient idea that one should not push too many pawns in the opening stirred a historical view of opening practice of olden time literature to witness the revolution toward pawn structures in conflict with itself.

White:  Magnus Carlsen   vs.  Black:  Sergey Karjakin   Opening:  Giuoco Piano

l. e4  e5  2.  Nf3  Nc6  3.  Bc4  Bc5  4. O-O  Nf6  5. d3  O-O  I call this the positional line (d3) where the plan is to avoid sharp aggression but known for a century or more.

6. a4  This square count sally was played against me by club member and my mentor Rev. George Switzer in the early 50s.  It was a practice game where I had introduced to him my concept so we agreed to give it a try.  Now I see it actually  played in a world championship contest!  The usual idea of the Giuoco pattern is c3 but allows the central thrust d5?! immediately if he so chooses, bucking up against the center for freedom.

6. … d6  7. c3  a6  8. b4  Having said A, white proceeds with B, again eyeing s/c.

8. … Ba7  9. Re1  To support the advanced e-pawn.

9. … Ne7  With the intention of resettling and finding activity on the kingside.

10. Nbd2  Ng6  11. d4!  It is important to counter his perceived black action and broaden his central space. Perhaps the genius of Carlsen shows itself here to entice black to force play in the center via 11…e:d4 and the important e-pawn is erased from it’s defensive task — the bulwark for defense in most KP openings. For example, 11…e:d4  12. c:d4  d5 13. e:d5  N:d5 black must weigh the consequences of 14. b5 or even 14. Ne4 emphasizing again s/c tactics.

11. … c6  12. h3  e:d4  The alternative here would be 12…Re8.

13. c:d4  N:e4  14. B:f7+!! An excellent idea.  White gets a pawn plus on the Kingside and better King protection.  This all is very double-edged and over my ability to suggest who is better at this point. Carlsen must have not liked any alternative thought. The idea seems logical and long term.

14. … R:f7  15. N:e4  d5!  To prevent the white isolated pawn from advancing. Lessons from MY SYSTEM by Nimsowitsch.

16.  Nc5!  h6  17. Ra3  A typical Carlsen type move where the Rook will be well positioned on the 3rd rank.  Black finds a good response if one thinks s/c.  Also, his forces are eyeing the King position which poses serious problems for white.

17. … Bf5  18. Ne5!  A necessary strike into enemy territory in order to achieve some exchange buffering the enemy assault.

18. … N:e5  19. d:e5  White envisions the a and c pawns holding up the black q/s majority. His hope probably rests with creating some k-side pawn activity where he stands better.

19. … Qh4!  20. Rf3  B:c5  This helps white because usually when you have the better attacking chances, you want to avoid unnecessary exchanges of pieces.

21. b:c5  Re8 22. Rf4  Qe7  23. Qd4!  Ref8  24. Rf3  Here doubling on the 3rd rank with Re3 is worth a look see.

24. … Be4  25. R:f7  Q:f7  26. f3  Bf5  27. Kh2  Be6  28 Re2  Qg6  29. Be3  Rf7  30. Rf2  Qb1  31. Rb2 Qf5  32. a5  I  was always aware that pawns should not be on the squares of the Bishop and seems to hold true here.  The advantage is that at least the b7 pawn is now dead in the water.

32… Kf8!! The King must be activated.

33. Qc3  Ke8  34. Rb4  g5! With this move Black gets a s/c edge 9/12.

35. Rb2  Kd8  36. Rf2  Kc8  37. Qd4  Qg6 38. g4 s/c 8/10

38. …h5  39. Qd2 Rg7 40. Kg3  Rg8 41. Kg2  And now White just needs to avoid falling into a mate.

41. … h:g4  42. h:g4  d4  43. Q:d4  Bd5  44. e6  Q:e6  45. Kg3 Qe7 46. Rh2 Qf7  47. f4  g:f4+ 48. Q:f4  Qe7  49. Rh5  Rf8  50. Rh7 R:f4  51. R:e7 Re4  Draw agreed to here.





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: